People talk about brunch like it’s some gastronomic milestone. They hype the “scene,” the experience, the $18 pancakes with foam and candied something. But ask ten locals why they actually show up on Saturday or Sunday morning and most will say something like:
“I had a rough night.”
“I didn’t feel like cooking.”
“It’s cheaper than dinner.”
Or the most honest one:
“It’s the only time you can drink and not sound like a mess.”
That’s not culture. That’s economics with intolerance to sobriety before lunch. Look around a brunch crowd anywhere in the city and you’ll see what I mean. People aren’t focused on eggs. They’re focused on validation. They want photos of bottomless drinks. They want captions about “making memories.” They want to look like they rested, even if they didn’t.
This is especially wild because New York wasn’t always like this. There was a time when brunch simply meant you got food at midday, and few chefs tried to turn it into an event. You went to a diner, you had eggs and coffee, you left. Now it’s a gastronomic social contract where people judge your look, your outfit, your drink, and your table’s aesthetic long before the food even arrives.
Brunch has become less about sustenance and more about performance. It’s a block by block competition, who got the cutest table, who got the furthest filtered photo, who managed to post a shot before someone else did. People spend more time photographing their brunch than eating it, then call it “culture.”
Don’t get me wrong, I understand why. NYC days are long, rents are high, rest is rare, and weekends feel tiny. Brunch offers a sanctioned space to delay productivity, to drink before society says it’s okay. But that doesn’t make it noble. It makes it a coping mechanism dressed up in linen napkins and curated playlists.
Meanwhile, real food culture, the kind that feeds people, not photo feeds gets overlooked. The diner that serves a proper omelet at 10 a.m. without pretension. The corner café where the coffee actually wakes you up instead of being iced and foamed for looks. The spot where you go because you know the food hits, not because someone tagged it as #brunchworthy.
This mess shows up in how people spend money too. A $28 avocado toast with sparkling water and a $150 tab because someone decided bottomless meant “spend without thinking.” That’s not culinary exploration. That’s leveraging alcohol to justify spending way more than the food itself is worth.
So what’s a real New Yorker to do if they want a Sunday morning meal without the brunch theatre?
1. Begin with purpose, not profile.
Ask yourself first: Do I want a meal or an event? They’re different. A meal feeds you. An event feeds someone’s marketing.
2. Choose places that feed locals, not likes.
Neighborhood diners, hidden bodegas with breakfast windows, Italian cafes that open early. These places know how to feed you without conditions.
3. Respect your wallet over the hype loop.
If half your tab is drinks styled for photos, ask whether that was brunch or a budget drain.
4. Drink before brunch without apology, just call it what it is.
A late night bleed into morning energy. Nothing wrong with that. Just don’t call it culture.
Here’s the messy part: brunch isn’t going away. People love it because it’s an easy excuse to be social while lying about being tired. It’s a sanctioned space to be cheesy and careless and indulgent. That’s fine. What isn’t fine is pretending it’s high culture or the apex of New York food life.
When New York talks about food identity, we talk about late-night pizza slices, the bodega egg sandwich that hits after a show, the corner joint that knows your order. Those are food realities. Brunch is a daytime drinking performance with food as an accessory.
If you want culture, eat the food that’s been trusted on the block for years without flashing emerald juice or mimosa towers. That’s where New York’s real flavor lives.
Brunch is fun. But let’s stop pretending it’s anything more than drinks with a late start time.
Like this? Explore more from:
