Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, Nov. 26, and the prices are posted. Carbone, at 181 Thompson Street, charges $295 a person for its Thanksgiving Supper. The Smith, which has four restaurants in Manhattan, charges $88. Both serve turkey. In the supermarket, a frozen turkey is advertised at an average of $1.19 a pound, by the federal government's weekly count of grocery ads. So the bird is cheap and the dinner around it can cost almost anything. We read both menus line by line, did the math on a table of four, lined up 16 New York dinners by price, and priced the turkey itself.

Stock photo by Karolina Grabowska on Pexels.
CARBONE PUTS FOURTEEN DISHES ON THE TABLE AND NOBODY CHOOSES BETWEEN ANY OF THEM
Carbone's website has a Thanksgiving tab in its menu section. The price line reads $295 per person, with "all courses served for the table." A meal sold this way is called a prix fixe: one set menu at one price.
The menu is titled Thanksgiving Supper and it comes in four rounds. First, four starters: Caesar alla ZZ, shrimp cocktail, carpaccio Piemontese, and prosciutto with pear. Then three more plates: spicy rigatoni vodka, pumpkin tortellini and Mario's meatballs. Then the bird, a glazed turkey breast, with cornbread stuffing, mashed potatoes, squash agrodolce (squash in a sweet-and-sour sauce) and cranberry mostarda (fruit preserved with mustard). Dessert is pecan pie and pumpkin cheesecake. That's 14 dishes. The page offers no choices, so everybody at the table gets all of it.
Five of those dishes sit on Carbone's regular dinner menu with prices: the carpaccio at $41, the Caesar at $35, the rigatoni at $34, the prosciutto and pear at $29 and the meatballs at $27. That's $166 if a table ordered one of each on a normal night. How many plates of each a party of four gets on Thanksgiving isn't on the page. Neither is a year. The tab says Thanksgiving and nothing more, and it was live when we opened it on Nov. 9. Carbone's Christmas menu, on the next tab, is also $295. We found no public statement from Carbone about the price beyond the menu itself.

Stock photo by Alexy Almond on Pexels.
THE SMITH CHARGES $88 FOR THREE COURSES AND LETS EVERY GUEST CHOOSE EACH ONE
The Smith's site lists four New York restaurants, in NoMad, Lincoln Square, Midtown and the East Village, and posts one Thanksgiving menu for the city. It's served Nov. 26 from noon to 9 p.m., and the page promises "we'll do the dishes." The menu itself is one page, with the number 88 next to the words Thanksgiving Dinner. Each guest picks a starter, a main and a dessert.
There are six starters: butternut squash soup, a kale and quinoa salad, ricotta gnocchi in truffle cream, tuna crudo, burrata, and a honeycrisp apple and celery salad. There are six mains, and three of them are turkey: a pot pie of braised thighs under a cheddar biscuit, a turkey leg osso buco (a slow-braised leg) over jalapeño cheddar grits, and roasted breast with garlic whipped potatoes and sage gravy. The other three are butternut squash risotto, roasted salmon and braised short rib. Dessert is chocolate cake, an apple tart or pumpkin spice cake. Three sides come to every table, included in the price: apple brioche stuffing, crispy Brussels sprouts and cranberry orange jam.
Set the two side by side. Starters: Carbone serves four, The Smith lets you pick one of six. A pasta round: Carbone serves three plates, The Smith has none. Turkey: Carbone serves breast one way, The Smith offers it three ways and you pick one. Sides: four at Carbone, three at The Smith, plus whatever comes on your plate. Dessert: both of Carbone's, one of The Smith's three. Extras: The Smith sells oysters at $4 each and three add-on dishes at $16 to $21. Carbone lists none. Neither menu includes a drink.
So the $207 difference buys 14 dishes against three plates and three shared sides, a pasta course, and no decisions. It also buys the table. Carbone's own homepage links a New Yorker story titled How to Get a Table at Carbone.
SALES TAX ALONE TURNS FOUR SEATS AT CARBONE INTO $1,284.73 BEFORE ANYONE ORDERS A DRINK
Neither menu says tax or service is included. The city's Department of Finance puts the sales tax on restaurant food and drinks at 8.875 percent: 4.5 for the city, 4 for the state and 0.375 for the transit district.
Four people at Carbone come to $1,180 for the food. Sales tax adds $104.73. The table is at $1,284.73, about $321 a person, before anyone orders a drink.
The same math at The Smith: $352 for four and $31.24 in tax, $383.24 in all, about $96 a person. The two tables are $901.49 apart.

Stock photo by cottonbro studio on Pexels.
SIXTEEN NEW YORK THANKSGIVING DINNERS RUN FROM $58 DOWNTOWN TO $295 ON THOMPSON STREET
Here is the ladder, cheapest first, with where each price comes from.
Eataly's downtown restaurants, $58, on Foodgressing's list. Nice Matin, $72, on LovelyNYC's list, which says it checked each restaurant's own page on Oct. 30. The Smith, $88, from its own page. Bubby's in Tribeca, $125, Delmonico's in the Financial District, $150, and Keens in Midtown, $167, all from The Infatuation. Le Rock at Rockefeller Center, $185, and Santi in Midtown, $190, from Forbes and The Infatuation. The Grill, on East 52nd Street, $215, with prime rib for $95 more, from its own page. Gramercy Tavern and Manhatta, $225 each, the River Café, $255, and The Modern's dining room, $275, from LovelyNYC.
Three sit at the top at $295. Carbone and Torrisi post it on their own pages. Daniel's three-course menu starts there, according to The Infatuation; Daniel's own site had no Thanksgiving page when we looked. Carbone, Torrisi and The Grill all link to one company, Major Food Group, at the bottom of their sites. One company runs two of the three most expensive dinners on this list.
This isn't every table in the city. It's the ones that posted a price.

Stock photo by Jackie A on Pexels.
THE SUPERMARKET SELLS THE BIRD FOR LESS THAN THE WHOLESALE MARKET CHARGES FOR IT
Every week the U.S. Department of Agriculture counts what supermarkets advertise. Its Nov. 6 report found frozen whole turkeys under 16 pounds at an average of $1.19 a pound across 9,794 stores, and bigger birds at $1.18. A year earlier the same lines read 93 and 92 cents. That's 26 cents more a pound, or 28 percent. A 16-pound bird comes to $19.04.
There are more turkeys this year. David Anderson, an economist at Texas A&M, said in a university release carried by High Plains Journal that the number of birds going to market is up about 3 percent and total production is up nearly 6 percent, after a drop of more than 8 percent last year.
The price went up anyway, and the wholesale market is part of the reason. Wholesale is what stores and restaurants pay suppliers. Anderson put whole turkeys at $1.80 a pound wholesale in late October, against $1.69 a year earlier. USDA's own report for the first week of November has frozen whole hens at $1.81. Last fall that price had jumped 70 percent, from 99 cents, he said. Shoppers didn't feel it then. The American Farm Bureau's 2025 survey found a 16-pound frozen turkey at $21.50, down more than 16 percent in a year, and a whole dinner for ten at $55.18. This year the ad price moved up 26 cents and the wholesale price moved up 11.
The supermarket is still selling the bird for about 60 cents a pound under the wholesale rate. Anderson's explanation is that grocers contract for Thanksgiving turkeys well ahead and use them to pull shoppers in. A store, he said, "may have promotions to draw shoppers."
Now the plate. Carbone serves breast, and USDA's wholesale report prices boneless, skinless turkey breast at $3.08 a pound. Half a pound of it is $1.54. A full pound of whole frozen turkey at the wholesale rate is $1.81. Those are market prices for ordinary birds. The Smith's menu calls its turkey all natural heritage turkey, and neither restaurant has published what it pays. Nobody outside those kitchens has seen the invoice, and we won't guess at it.
The arithmetic holds at any of these prices. The turkey costs a dollar or two a portion, and the dinner around it costs $58, $88 or $295 before tax and a glass of anything. One seat at Carbone, tax in, costs almost six times what the Farm Bureau says a whole dinner for ten cost at home last year. On Thanksgiving the turkey is the cheapest thing on the table.
SOURCING
Carbone, menu section, Thanksgiving tab, opened Nov 9, 2026 ($295 per person, all courses served for the table, the 14 dishes; regular dinner prices for the carpaccio, Caesar, rigatoni, prosciutto and meatballs; the Christmas tab at $295; 181 Thompson Street; the New Yorker link; the Major Food Group footer links): https://carbonenewyork.com/
The Smith, Thanksgiving page (Thursday, November 26th, 12pm to 9pm, three courses, turkey three ways, the four New York restaurants): https://thesmithrestaurant.com/thanksgiving/
The Smith, New York Thanksgiving menu, 2026 PDF (Thanksgiving Dinner 88, six starters, six mains, three desserts, fixings for the table, oysters and additions): https://thesmithrestaurant.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/TS-NYC-Thanksgiving_2026.pdf
The Grill, menu section, Thanksgiving tab ($215 per person, prime rib $95 supplement, 99 East 52nd Street, Major Food Group footer links): https://thegrillnewyork.com/
Torrisi, menu section, Thanksgiving tab ($295 per person, Major Food Group footer links): https://torrisinyc.com/
Daniel, restaurant site (no Thanksgiving page as of Nov 9): https://www.danielnyc.com/
The Infatuation, Thanksgiving dinner guide, Nov 6, 2026 (Daniel from $295, The Grill $215, The Smith $88, Bubby's $125, Delmonico's $150, Keens $167, Le Rock $185, Santi $190): https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/guides/thanksgiving-dinner-nyc
LovelyNYC, Thanksgiving dinner list, checked Oct 30, 2026 (Carbone and Torrisi $295, Daniel $295, The Modern $275, River Café $255, Gramercy Tavern and Manhatta $225, Nice Matin $72; the note that Carbone's, Torrisi's and The Grill's pages print no year): https://lovelynyc.com/holidays/thanksgiving-dinner/
Foodgressing, Nov 6, 2026 (Eataly NYC Downtown $58, Manhatta $225): https://foodgressing.com/thanksgiving-nyc-2026-dinner-turkey-to-go-brunch/
Forbes, Melissa Kravitz Hoeffner, updated Oct 27, 2026 (Le Rock $185, Santi $190): https://www.forbes.com/sites/melissakravitz/2026/10/16/where-to-make-thanksgiving-dinner-reservations-in-new-york-city/
NYC Department of Finance, sales tax (food and beverages sold by restaurants; 4.5 percent city, 4 percent state, 0.375 percent transit district, 8.875 percent total): https://www.nyc.gov/site/finance/business/business-nys-sales-tax.page
USDA Agricultural Marketing Service, Weekly Grocery Store Turkey Feature Activity, Nov 6, 2026 edition (frozen conventional whole turkey under 16 pounds $1.19 at 9,794 stores, over 16 pounds $1.18; previous week $1.26; previous year 93 and 92 cents; 26 cents higher than a year ago). This address always shows the newest edition: https://www.ams.usda.gov/mnreports/ams_2867.pdf
USDA Agricultural Marketing Service, Weekly National Turkey Report, Nov 6, 2026 edition (frozen whole young hens, 8 to 16 pounds, 181.00 cents a pound; boneless, skinless tom breast 308.00 cents). This address always shows the newest edition: https://www.ams.usda.gov/mnreports/ams_3647.pdf
High Plains Journal, Texas A&M AgriLife release, Nov 6, 2026 (David Anderson: wholesale $1.80 against $1.69, the jump from 99 cents, birds up about 3 percent and pounds nearly 6 percent, last year's drop of more than 8 percent, grocers contracting ahead, the quote): https://hpj.com/2026/11/06/plenty-of-turkeys-this-thanksgiving-as-wholesale-prices-hold-steady/
Farms.com, Nov 21, 2025, on the American Farm Bureau's 2025 survey (dinner for ten $55.18, 16-pound frozen turkey $21.50, down more than 16 percent): https://www.farms.com/ag-industry-news/thanksgiving-dinner-costs-drop-again-in-2025-201.aspx








