If you’ve ever worked in a real kitchen, you know the dirty secret behind half the “house specials” in town: buckets of sauce from suppliers like Sysco or local distributors dumped into squeeze bottles and passed off as the chef’s special. The bucket sauce isn’t a shortcut that bothers me, it’s the lie.

Walk into half the Midtown lunchtime spots and you’ll see the industrial white buckets stacked in the walk-in, covered in marker scribbles. You know exactly what’s in them. You don’t need the new culinary dictionary to tell you that half those “secret family recipes” were purchased in bulk and slapped on the plate five minutes before service. That’s not craft. That’s convenience wearing a disguise.

Meanwhile, the Dominican spots in Washington Heights are slowly stewing their habichuelas and rice sauces for hours. West African kitchens in the Bronx bubble their stews and jollofs with intentional layering because that’s how the flavor builds. Those are sauces with memory and time behind them, not something scooped from a bucket at 11:45 a.m. And not getting nearly enough magazine spreads or hype cycles while every Midtown “concept lunch menu” celebrates its own version of a bucket disguise.

This city loves to pretend it’s about authenticity and culture, until it’s served a cheap shortcut with a clever name. Then we call it “elevated casual.” That’s marketing, not cooking. If your menu needs clever plating and a trendy name to distract from the fact that the sauce came from a bucket, then you’re not a chef — you’re a packager.

New Yorkers can taste time. We can taste depth. We can taste when a sauce was born in a pot over flame and when it was scooped from plastic the night before. It hits immediately. You don’t need a culinary degree. You need taste buds. And half the time, the spots that talk loudest about how “unique” they are are the ones hiding the biggest buckets.

Real kitchens don’t need to hide. They build flavor — and they’re proud of it. They let that sauce speak first, not some brand’s abbreviated archive in a bucket.

If you want to impress New Yorkers, start with sauce that speaks for itself — not one that whispers “we bought this whole.”

Like this? Explore more from: