By Leila Molitor.
Soft-serve used to be the most democratic substance in New York City. It was a $3 swirl of chemical-adjacent vanilla from a Mister Softee truck that lived on the corner of every block, sounding a jingle that triggered Pavlovian responses in children and heat-exhausted commuters alike. It was cheap, it was messy, and it was never meant to be a status symbol. Then, the artisanal movement of the 2010s arrived, and suddenly we were all standing in line in the East Village for Morgenstern’s or Big Gay Ice Cream. This was the "innocent" era when a premium sprinkle or a salty topping felt like a legitimate upgrade to our childhood nostalgia.
The shift into the absurd began with the arrival of the "Instagram cone." Taiyaki NYC in Chinatown was an early, unintentional architect of the chaos, introducing the fish-shaped waffle cone that looked better on a grid than it tasted in the humidity of July.1 It was cute, it was high-quality, but it signaled to the rest of the city that a cone wasn't a vessel; it was a frame. By the time we reached the mid-2020s, the trend had been hijacked by the "luxury" industrial complex. When Sasha Zabar opened Glace on the Upper East Side, he wasn't just selling ice cream; he was selling a $16 "s’mores" experience complete with a toasted marshmallow rim that requires a blowtorch and ten minutes of labor per serving.
The acceleration happened when the price point detached from the ingredients and attached itself to the "viral labor" of the assembly. Media outlets detonated the craze by labeling every new $15 swirl "the must-try dessert of the summer," while TikTok influencers realized that a video of a gold-leaf-topped matcha swirl garnered more engagement than actual taste-testing. The trend warped into a game of one-upmanship: if your soft-serve didn't come with a croissant-cone, a butter-dipped shell, or a literal mountain of toppings that make the ice cream structurally unsound, it didn't exist.
The NYC "ugh" reaction peaked when the lines for these "drops" began to block actual foot traffic on Lex and Madison. We reached a point where people were paying nearly twenty dollars for a substance that melts in six minutes, just to take a photo of it against a brick wall and throw half of it away because it’s cloyingly sweet and impossible to eat without a hazmat suit. The cultural fallout is a city full of "concept" creameries that care more about the lighting in the shop than the butterfat content of the dairy.
We’ve reached the end of the line when "soft-serve" is no longer a treat, but a calculated financial transaction designed to prove you were there. The simplicity of the swirl has been buried under a mountain of gimmickry and "limited edition" nonsense that makes us long for the days of a simple cardboard cup and a plastic spoon.
So who ruined it? Taiyaki made it. Grub Street detonated it. TikTok worshipped it. And the rest of us? We were just trying to get to work without stepping over people photographing a melting marshmallow-rimmed cup on a fire hydrant in the middle of a heatwave.
Like this? Explore more from:
