The menu you call tradition has receipts. Not one of the dishes on that table descended from Plymouth, and most of them are younger than your grandmother. They were written, canned, patented and advertised into the American kitchen by people who were selling something, in an order you can follow year by year.

THE SETUP

Thanksgiving is the most successful product launch in American history. It was assembled over 126 years by a magazine editor, a bog owner, three test kitchens and a poultry lobby, then sold back to us as heritage. That is worth knowing, not because the holiday is fake, but because the part nobody engineered is the part that is actually ours.

One editor wrote the menu, then lobbied five presidents to make it law

Sarah Josepha Hale edited Godey's Lady's Book, the most widely read women's magazine in nineteenth century America. For seventeen years she printed turkey, stuffing and pumpkin pie in her pages as the national bill of fare, and she wrote to five sitting presidents asking them to make the holiday official. Lincoln proclaimed it in 1863. A Smithsonian curator credits her as central to popularizing both the holiday and the menu attached to it.

She was not recording a tradition. She was writing one, and she had the circulation to make it stick. Everything that follows is a company taking the handoff.

Your table was shipped in this order

THE PRODUCT TIMELINE

Cranberry, first canned by Marcus Urann

1912

Libby's buys the Dickinson squash operation

1929

A retail lobby moves the date

1939

The jellied cranberry log goes nationwide

1941

Green Bean Bake, Camden NJ test kitchen

1955

Stove Top ships from a marketing ask

1972

Forty percent of Campbell's mushroom soup goes into one 1955 recipe

Dorcas Reilly built what she called Green Bean Bake in Campbell's Camden, New Jersey test kitchen in 1955, for an Associated Press feature. It did not take off until Campbell's printed it on the soup can. The company now estimates that forty percent of its US cream of mushroom soup ends up in that single dish.

Stove Top has a cleaner paper trail. Ruth Siems, a food scientist at General Foods, built it because the marketing department asked for a stuffing that did not require a loaf of stale bread. It shipped in 1972. Kraft now moves roughly sixty million boxes at Thanksgiving.

The pie is the same story told with squash. Libby's bought the Dickinson operation in 1929, still grows its own proprietary strain, printed the pie recipe on the back of the can in the 1950s, and today produces about eighty five percent of America's canned pumpkin, enough for something near ninety million pies a year. Botanically the contents read closer to butternut squash than to anything you would find in a pumpkin patch.

Cranberry went first. Marcus Urann, a lawyer who bought a bog, canned cranberries in 1912, and the jellied log went national in 1941. Only about five percent of the US crop is still sold as fresh fruit. The ridges from the can are not a serving suggestion. They are the product.

A retail lobby moved the holiday to stretch the shopping season

In August 1939, Lew Hahn of the Retail Dry Goods Association warned Commerce Secretary Harry Hopkins that a late Thanksgiving would cut into holiday goods sales. Roosevelt moved the holiday a week earlier to lengthen the run to Christmas. The country called it Franksgiving and largely hated it. A 1941 Commerce survey found no meaningful sales lift, and Congress settled the date on the fourth Thursday.

The date on your calendar is the residue of a retail lobby's bad guess.

Even the bird comes with a trade group attached. The National Turkey Federation has presented a live Broad Breasted White to the president every year since 1947, a bird bred for breast size at the cost of its own health. The ceremony is an annual press hit for an industry.

Nobody ran a test kitchen on the pernil.

The part nobody engineered

Here is what the receipts do not cover. The pernil in Soundview. The mac and cheese that outranks the turkey in Harlem. The curry goat in East Flatbush, the lechon on a folding table in Woodside, the pot of rice and beans that feeds twelve and costs almost nothing. The extra pot because cousins are coming.

None of that came off a can or out of a test kitchen. It got to the table the long way, from somebody's grandmother, through a kitchen in a neighborhood no magazine editor was writing menus for. The holiday the ads sell you is one meal. The one this city actually eats is five boroughs deep, and it has never needed a brand.

The canned stuff has a patent number. Your plate has a family.

Sources

  • Sarah Josepha Hale and the Godey's Lady's Book campaign, Smithsonian and Women's eNews

  • Marcus Urann and the first canned cranberry sauce, Smithsonian

  • Libby's Dickinson strain and canned pumpkin share, Food Network and Chicago Sun-Times

  • Dorcas Reilly and Green Bean Bake, Smithsonian and Food Processing

  • Ruth Siems and Stove Top, Purdue University

  • National Turkey Federation presentation history, eatturkey.org

  • Franksgiving and the 1941 Commerce survey, HistoryNet

Reply

Avatar

or to participate