A Brown Butter Pumpkin pie from Four & Twenty Blackbirds costs $46. That's the price on the bakery's Thanksgiving menu, for pickup at its shop at 439 Third Avenue in Gowanus from Sunday, Nov. 22, through Thanksgiving morning, and local delivery for the week is already sold out. It's also what the shop charges for every whole pie on its regular menu, from Salty Honey to Lemon Chess, so this is the house price with no holiday bump. Each pie is 10 inches and cuts into eight to ten slices, the bakery says.

A pumpkin pie on a wooden table with one slice cut out and a fork and knife at the edge

Illustrative photo. Pexels.

Costco's pumpkin pie is $5.99. It came back to warehouses in August at what Tasting Table called its "good old price of $5.99," and The Takeout put it at 58 ounces, more than three and a half pounds. Entrepreneur reported the same $5.99 in 2023 and said it hadn't changed since 2022. So the gap is $40.01, and every November somebody in the group chat asks what it pays for.

We built the receipt. The price is public. The cost model is ours. Every number under $46 below is our estimate, built from government price data and published industry benchmarks. We don't have Four & Twenty's recipe cards, invoices, lease or payroll, and nothing here pretends we do.

EGGS AND BUTTER GOT CHEAPER THIS YEAR, AND THE PIE STILL COSTS $46

Start with what everyone assumes. Pumpkin pie is a custard pie, and custard means eggs. Eggs were the 2025 story, and this year they went the other way. The USDA's Economic Research Service, in its Oct. 23 outlook, expects retail egg prices to finish 2026 down 29.3 percent. The Bureau of Labor Statistics average for a dozen large Grade A eggs was $2.27 in September, against $3.49 a year earlier.

Butter fell too. The BLS average for a pound was $3.96 in September, down from $4.79 a year before, about 17 percent. Flour sat near 55 cents a pound and white sugar near $1.02, both a little under where they were last September.

Run those through our pie and the two that fell, eggs and butter, take about 77 cents off the ingredient bill compared with a year ago. Across a whole Thanksgiving week of baking, that adds up. On one $46 pie, it's small. The rest of the gap lives somewhere else.

THE INGREDIENTS IN A 10-INCH BROWN BUTTER PUMPKIN PIE COME TO ABOUT $10.50

Four & Twenty doesn't publish its recipe, so we built a standard one at the shop's size. A 10-inch all-butter crust plus a brown butter filling takes about seven ounces of butter, which at September's average comes to about $1.75. Four large eggs are 76 cents. About a cup of brown and white sugar is 51 cents, and the flour for the crust is 23 cents.

Hands working dough on a floured table with eggs at the edge of the frame

Illustrative photo. Pexels.

The two ingredients the government doesn't track are the expensive ones. We put about two and a half cups of pumpkin or squash puree at $3.25 and a cup and a half of heavy cream at $3, both our estimates at New York retail. Spice, vanilla and salt add about a dollar. The total is about $10.50, or 23 percent of the price.

Those are U.S. retail averages, and that cuts both ways. A bakery buying butter and cream by the case pays less per pound. A bakery buying from farms, the way Four & Twenty says it buys Hudson Valley apples, pays more. Our band runs from $8.50 to $12.50. Toast, the restaurant software company, puts bakery food costs at 30 to 35 percent of sales, and Restaurant365's default band is 26 to 30. By either yardstick this pie's ingredients run lean. Most of your $46 goes somewhere other than the pie plate.

THE BAKERS, THE BOX, THE GOWANUS SPACE AND THE GAS BILL TAKE ABOUT $31 MORE

The box is the easy line. A sturdy 10-inch pie box with a board under the pie runs about $1 to $2.50 at our estimate. We used $1.75.

The biggest line is people. The founders, sisters Emily and Melissa Elsen, wrote that they opened the shop to make pie in "a truly handmade way." Handmade means hours: rolling and crimping crusts, browning butter, baking, cooling and boxing, plus a counter that's open seven days a week. New York City's minimum wage is $17 an hour, and the state Labor Department says it stays at $17 on Jan. 1, 2027. Toast puts bakery labor at 24 to 40 percent of sales. For a shop that makes everything by hand, we used 34 to 40 percent, with 38 in the middle. That's $17.48 a pie, inside a band of $15.64 to $18.40.

Forearms rolling out dough with a wooden pin on a floured counter, shot from above

Illustrative photo. Pexels.

Then the space. The National Restaurant Association's latest operations survey put median occupancy costs for city restaurants at 6 percent of sales in 2024. A pie shop needs a big kitchen behind a small counter, so we ran 6 to 10 percent, with 8 in the middle. That's $3.68 a pie, in a band of $2.76 to $4.60. We don't know Four & Twenty's rent, and we don't state it.

Then everything else: gas for the ovens, power for the walk-in, insurance, repairs, cleaning, the ordering website and the accountant. Energy prices in the New York area rose 21.5 percent in the year to September, the BLS says, and a bakery runs its ovens all day. We put this line at 16 to 20 percent of the price, 18 in the middle, or $8.28.

The box, the labor, the space and the rest come to about $31.19. Add the ingredients and the pie has used $41.69 of your $46.

A GOWANUS PIE SHOP HAS TO SELL ABOUT 36 PIES A DAY TO BREAK EVEN

Per-pie math hides something. Most of those costs arrive whether anyone buys a pie or not. So we ran it the other way. Take $46, subtract our $10.50 of ingredients and $1.75 for the box, and each pie leaves $33.75 to pay for everything that doesn't grow with the oven.

Here's a modest day at a small shop, in our model. Rent of about $7,500 a month is $250 a day, inside Toast's $1,500 to $10,000 monthly range for bakery rent. A crew of four working eight hours at $20 an hour, a little over the minimum, plus payroll taxes, is about $700. Gas, power, insurance and the rest add about $250. Call it $1,200 a day.

A knife cutting into a pumpkin pie topped with pastry leaves

Illustrative photo. Pexels.

$1,200 divided by $33.75 is 35.6. Round up and the shop sells about 36 whole pies a day, every day it's open, before it clears a dollar. Slices and coffee count toward that number, and so do pre-orders, which is why one week in November carries so much of a pie shop's year.

AFTER EVERY LINE, THE SHOP KEEPS ABOUT $4.30 ON A $46 PIE

Now the line the slides leave off. Ingredients, $10.50. The box, $1.75. Labor, $17.48. Space, $3.68. Everything else, $8.28. That's $41.69. Out of $46, about $4.31 is left, roughly 9 percent, before income taxes, loan payments and anything the owners put back into the shop. Restaurant365 calls 6 to 10 percent a good net margin in its default band. Toast says most food businesses land between 3 and 5.

Run our bands the bad way, with the top of every range, and the last line drops below zero. Run them the good way and it's about $10.75. The honest answer is a band: nothing to about $10, with about $4 in the middle. That $4 is what pays for the name, 17 years of the same Salty Honey and Brown Butter Pumpkin, a cookbook, and the reason people order in October.

Hands reaching across a wooden table around a pumpkin pie

Illustrative photo. Pexels.

Costco's pie runs on different math. It's 58 ounces for $5.99, and in 2023 Entrepreneur, citing authors David and Susan Schwartz, reported that Costco sells more than six million pies between September and December. Costco doesn't publish what one costs it to bake, and we don't guess. A warehouse that moves pies by the million and a Gowanus counter that moves them by the dozen run on two different cost structures.

So the ruling is fair. $46 is a lot for a pie you'll finish in one night, and it's a lot because about $17 of it is people's hands, about $10.50 is butter, eggs, cream and pumpkin, and most of the rest is the space, the ovens and the box. Cut eight ways it's $5.75 a slice, and Petee's Pie charges $45 for its full-size pumpkin this Thanksgiving. The shop's own share is about $4. Cheaper eggs moved our model by about 40 cents. The other $40 pays for hands, heat and a lease in Brooklyn.

SOURCING

Four & Twenty Blackbirds, Thanksgiving 2026 menu, opened Nov 4: Brown Butter Pumpkin $46, all four pies $46, pickup Nov 22 to 26, local delivery sold out, Hudson Valley apples. birdsblack.com

Four & Twenty Blackbirds, Thanksgiving FAQ, opened Nov 4: 10 inches, 8 to 10 slices, $46 each, pickup at the Gowanus shop. birdsblack.com

Four & Twenty Blackbirds, FAQ, opened Nov 4: whole pies are 10 inches and serve 8 to 10. birdsblack.com

Four & Twenty Blackbirds, full menu, opened Nov 4: every whole pie $46. birdsblack.com

Four & Twenty Blackbirds, location and hours, opened Nov 4: 439 Third Avenue, Gowanus, open seven days. birdsblack.com

Four & Twenty Blackbirds, About, opened Nov 4: founded 2009 by Emily and Melissa Elsen, Gowanus shop since spring 2010. birdsblack.com

Petee's Pie, Thanksgiving orders, opened Nov 4: full-size pumpkin $45. peteesthanksgiving.myshopify.com

Tasting Table, Aug 24, 2026: Costco pie back at $5.99. tastingtable.com

The Takeout, Aug 24, 2026: $5.99, 58 ounces. thetakeout.com

Entrepreneur, Nov 21, 2023: $5.99 unchanged from 2022, more than six million pies September to December, per David and Susan Schwartz. entrepreneur.com

USDA ERS, Food Price Outlook, Oct 23, 2026: eggs down 29.3 percent in 2026. ers.usda.gov

Food World News, Oct 14, 2026: eggs down 29.4 percent in the September outlook. foodworldnews.com

BLS average price, eggs, Grade A large, via FRED: $3.488 Sept 2025, $2.272 Sept 2026. fred.stlouisfed.org

BLS average price, butter, via FRED: $4.787 Sept 2025, $3.959 Sept 2026. fred.stlouisfed.org

BLS average price, flour, via FRED: $0.563 Sept 2025, $0.545 Sept 2026. fred.stlouisfed.org

BLS average price, white sugar, via FRED: $1.042 Sept 2025, $1.019 Sept 2026. fred.stlouisfed.org

BLS, CPI New York-Newark-Jersey City, September 2026, released Oct 14: energy up 21.5 percent. bls.gov

New York State Department of Labor, minimum wage: $17.00 in New York City, unchanged on Jan 1, 2027. dol.ny.gov

Toast, How Much Do Bakeries Make: food 30 to 35 percent of sales, labor 24 to 40 percent, rent $1,500 to $10,000 a month, food businesses 3 to 5 percent margin. pos.toasttab.com

Restaurant365, profitability thresholds by restaurant type: default food cost 26 to 30 percent, net margin 6 to 10 percent. docs.restaurant365.com

National Restaurant Association, Sept 3, 2025: 2024 occupancy medians, urban 6.0 percent. restaurant.org

Photos: Pexels. Illustrative, not taken at Four & Twenty Blackbirds and not its pies.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate