Friday’s post was about a bagel chain that won’t sell you one bagel. This one is about the counters that will, and what they charge for it. On Nov. 4 we priced one plain bagel, no spread, no slicing extras, before tax, at 11 New York shops. Every price came from the shop’s own menu page or its direct online ordering page, opened that day. Six counters are in Brooklyn, four in Manhattan and one in Queens. The cheapest plain bagel we found costs $1.50. The most expensive costs 68 cents more. Here is the whole list, and what it says about a city that still lets you buy one.

A hand spreading cream cheese on a sliced plain bagel held in paper

A bagel with cream cheese runs from $3.25 to $4.50 where the menus list it. Photo: Pexels.

BAGEL STREET ON PARK AVENUE SOUTH SELLS THE CHEAPEST PLAIN BAGEL WE FOUND AT $1.50

The lowest price on our list is on Park Avenue South. Bagel Street, at 437 Park Avenue South in NoMad, lists a single bagel at $1.50 on its ordering page, and choosing plain costs nothing extra. A buttered bagel is $2.99 and a bagel with plain cream cheese is $3.99. A baker’s dozen, 13 bagels, is $21. The shop calls itself a neighborhood bagel and sandwich shop and opens at 6 AM on weekdays and 6:30 on weekends.

Four shops tie for second at $1.75. Bagels on the Square, at 7 Carmine Street in the West Village, sells a single for $1.75, a buttered bagel for $1.95 and a bagel with cream cheese for $3.25, the lowest cream cheese price we saw. Bagels by the Park, at 323 Smith Street in Carroll Gardens, starts its build-a-bagel at $1.75 with plain at no charge. Bagel Point, at 699 Manhattan Avenue in Greenpoint, sells a plain bagel for $1.75, a buttered one for $3 and one with plain cream cheese for $3.95. Brothers Bagels, at 532 Neptune Avenue in Coney Island, lists its bagel at $1.75 under a menu heading that says the baking is done on the premises.

Toasted sesame bagels on black slate boards

Five of the 11 counters charge $1.75 or less for a plain bagel. Photo: Pexels.

ELEVEN COUNTERS ACROSS THREE BOROUGHS PRICE ONE PLAIN BAGEL BETWEEN $1.50 AND $2.18

The middle of the list is tight. La Bagel Delight, at 73 Lafayette Avenue in Fort Greene, charges $1.80 for a single bagel, plain included. Bagels & Co., at 1428 York Avenue on the Upper East Side, charges $1.85. Three shops sit at exactly $2: Utopia Bagels at 19-09 Utopia Parkway in Whitestone, Brooklyn Bagel BP at 5702 18th Avenue in Borough Park, and Bagel Pub in Park Slope, whose menu page lists a bagel at $2 across its shops.

Put the 11 in a line and the median plain bagel costs $1.80. The average works out to $1.85. Nobody we priced asks more than $2.18 for one plain bagel, and five of the 11 charge $1.75 or less. Three of those five are in Brooklyn. The two Upper East Side counters on the list, on York Avenue and Second Avenue, land at $1.85 and $2.18.

The list has gaps, and they’re worth naming. We couldn’t open a live single-bagel price for any Bronx or Staten Island counter by our deadline, so this ranking covers three boroughs. Some of the best-known names aren’t on it for the same reason: Ess-a-Bagel’s own menu lists the individual bagel without a price, and we couldn’t open a live single price for Tompkins Square Bagels, Russ & Daughters, Zabar’s or Absolute Bagels. Where a shop’s ordering system added an online markup to its single bagel, we left the shop out, because that price isn’t what you pay at the counter. Yossi’s Bagels on Kings Highway was showing that it wasn’t taking orders when we checked, so it’s out too. Online prices can still differ from the register. If yours does, tell us and we’ll update the list.

PICK-A-BAGEL ON SECOND AVENUE CHARGES THE MOST OF THE 11 AT $2.18 A BAGEL

The top of our list is Pick-a-Bagel at 1475 Second Avenue on the Upper East Side, where a single bagel costs $2.18 and choosing plain costs nothing extra. A buttered bagel there is $3.95. Pick-a-Bagel runs several Manhattan shops, and at its 1101 Lexington Avenue location the ordering page lists a hand-rolled bagel at $3.18 and flags an online markup on it, which is why we priced the Second Avenue counter instead.

That’s the most expensive plain bagel on the list, 68 cents over the cheapest. The real spread in New York bagels shows up once something goes on top. Where the menus list it, a bagel with cream cheese runs from $3.25 at Bagels on the Square to $4.50 at Utopia, and a buttered bagel goes from $1.95 on Carmine Street to $3.95 on Second Avenue. The plain bagel itself barely moves.

Buying more drops the price further. Bagels on the Square sells a dozen for $18.95, about $1.58 a bagel. Bagel Street’s baker’s dozen is 13 bagels for $21, about $1.62 each. Utopia’s baker’s dozen starts at $24, and Pick-a-Bagel’s on Second Avenue is $26.16, about $2.01 a bagel. The priciest bag we found still works out to roughly what Utopia, Bagel Pub and Brooklyn Bagel BP charge for a single. None of these counters needs you to buy a bag to get in the door.

A pile of plain and everything bagels on a wooden board

The median plain bagel on our list costs $1.80. Photo: Pexels.

UTOPIA HAS SOLD BAGELS IN WHITESTONE SINCE 1981 AND TAKES BAGELFEST’S LIFETIME AWARD TODAY

Utopia is the reason this post runs today. The shop has been in Whitestone since 1981, according to its own site, and it now runs four locations: Whitestone, Midtown, Long Island City and Third Avenue. We priced only Whitestone. There, the menu lists a plain bagel at $2, a bagel with butter or jelly at $3.50, a bagel with plain cream cheese at $4.50, and a baker’s dozen starting at $24. The doors on Utopia Parkway open at 5 AM.

Today BagelFest, in its seventh year, takes over Citi Field. According to amNY, 25 bagel makers each submit a dozen unsliced plain bagels, and a panel tastes them blind, scoring taste, texture, appearance and aroma over several rounds until three remain. Awards go to Best Bagel, Schmear of the Year and a People’s Choice voted by guests. Founder Sam Silverman called it the “most prestigious bagel competition in the world.” Utopia won Best Bagel in 2024, amNY reported, and today it receives the 2026 Lifetime Achievement Award, which went to Ess-a-Bagel and Absolute Bagels before it. Utopia is also scheduled to talk about its 1981 start on stage with chef Christian Petroni.

Two whole bagels on a dark surface

BagelFest judges taste a dozen unsliced bagels from each of 25 makers. Photo: Pexels.

Now the comparison Friday set up. PopUp Bagels, which Adam Goldberg founded in Westport, Connecticut, in 2020, sells combos only: three or six bagels with one eight-ounce tub of schmear, or a dozen with two. When Tribeca Citizen visited the Greenwich Street store in February, the smallest order was simple: “Three plus the one schmear was $13.” The store had no seating. QSR, citing Bloomberg, reported that Tiger Global invested at a $300 million valuation, that the private equity firm Stripes is the largest investor, and that PopUp’s average ticket runs north of $24. It had 300 locations signed and wants about 100 open by the end of 2027.

Do the math on the combo and PopUp’s bagel comes to about $4.33 each with a third of a tub. That’s less than Utopia’s $4.50 bagel with cream cheese and more than Bagels on the Square’s $3.25. So the fight comes down to the minimum order. At Bagel Street, $13 buys eight plain bagels and leaves change. At every counter on this list, you can walk in hungry, hand over $2.18 or less, and walk out with one bagel. At PopUp, the smallest check is $13 before you’ve tasted anything.

Bagels with cream cheese and smoked salmon on slate boards

PopUp’s smallest order is three bagels and one tub of schmear. Photo: Pexels.

A chain built on bags wants the average ticket over $24. A counter that sells you one bagel for $1.50 is betting you’ll come back tomorrow, and the day after that. Eleven shops in three boroughs still make that bet every morning, and the most any of them asks for one plain bagel is $2.18.

SOURCING

Photos: Pexels.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate