By Leila Molitor.
Ketchup is the participation trophy of condiments. It is the red-tinted lens through which we view a childhood that probably wasn't as sweet as the 4 grams of sugar per tablespoon suggests. We call it a "staple," but let’s be real… it’s a mask. It’s what you use when the kitchen fails, or when your palate peaked in the third grade. It’s the ultimate edible gaslighter, convincing you that a dry-aged ribeye and a lukewarm chicken nugget are essentially the same delivery system for vinegar and salt.
Before it was the American sugar-bomb we know today, ketchup was ke-chiap—a fermented fish sauce from 17th-century China that would make a modern suburban toddler weep. The British tried to replicate it with mushrooms and walnuts, but it wasn't until 1812 that some guy in Philadelphia threw tomatoes into the mix. By the time Henry Heinz figured out how to bottle it without it exploding on the shelf, the transition from "complex fermented umami" to "thick red candy" was complete. We traded soul for shelf-stability.
Ketchup is the "Nice Guy" of the fridge. Predictable, clingy, and surprisingly basic. It doesn't have the audacity of mustard or the quiet sophistication of a kewpie mayo. It’s the condiment of the risk-averse. If your fridge contains nothing but a crusty bottle of Hunt’s, you probably still have your childhood bedroom exactly how you left it. It represents a refusal to engage with the bitterness of the real world, preferring instead to drown everything in a high-fructose security net.
Nothing exposes a New York transplant faster than their ketchup etiquette. You see them at a corner bodega at 2:00 AM, demanding "extra packets" for a chopped cheese that’s already perfect. Or worse, the Midtown tourist putting it on a Nathan’s hot dog, a felony in all five boroughs. In this city, ketchup is the mark of the uninitiated. Real New Yorkers know that if the food is good, the red bottle stays in the crate. It’s a tool for survival, used only to lubricate a $5 street-cart pretzel that’s been sitting in the sun since the Bloomberg administration.
We don’t love ketchup for the taste; we love it because we’re terrified of change. It is the culinary baseline, the red tether keeping us connected to a time when our biggest problem was the crust on our white bread. It’s a mediocre sauce for a mediocre world. Enjoy your nostalgia, just keep it off my steak.
Like this? Explore more from:
