Every food magazine in this country is in the business of crowning a coolest chef. The criteria is consistent. A sneaker drop. A tasting menu with seventeen courses. A Michelin star or three. A New Yorker profile. A guest spot on a podcast hosted by another chef who also has a Michelin star. A capsule collection with a streetwear label nobody under thirty has ever heard of.
The criteria does not include showing up to a congressional hearing in a suit you bought yourself and explaining to senators what a 4 percent food cost margin actually means.
That is what Tom Colicchio has been doing for the better part of fifteen years. And it is why he is the coolest chef in America.
What he actually did
In March 2020 the restaurant industry was looking at extinction. Independent operators were closing nationwide. PPP was built for businesses that meet payroll on a regular cycle, not for restaurants where rent and food cost and labor swing every week. Vendors were not getting paid. Line cooks were being told to file for unemployment in states that had broken unemployment systems and unemployment offices that were not picking up the phone.
Colicchio co-founded the Independent Restaurant Coalition. He went to Washington. He testified to Congress. He spent the first eighteen months of the pandemic in DC instead of in his kitchen, lobbying for relief structured for independent restaurants and not for the publicly traded chains that had eaten the first round of CARES Act money before the ink was dry.
The Restaurant Revitalization Fund was the result. $28.6 billion appropriated through the American Rescue Plan, signed into law in March 2021. Money structured to go directly to operators. No bank intermediary. No loan to repay. Grants calculated against actual revenue loss.
The receipts
The numbers tell two stories.
First story: roughly 100,000 independent restaurants got funded. Most of them family-owned. Most under $1.5 million in annual revenue. Sixty percent of recipients reported as women-owned. Nearly half identified as socially or economically disadvantaged. The first 21 days of the program prioritized those operators specifically. That was the structural choice the IRC fought for and won.
Second story: the fund ran out. The SBA received over 278,000 applications totaling more than $72 billion in requested relief. They had $28.6 billion to give. About 40 percent of eligible applicants got funded. The other 60 percent watched the money disappear and were told the program was closed.
The RESTAURANTS Act, bipartisan legislation that would have replenished the fund with $120 billion, has been stuck in Congress since 2021. Colicchio has not stopped lobbying for it. Most chefs would have stopped after the first round passed and gone back to the kitchen. He did not.
What he keeps saying out loud
The IRC was not the first time Colicchio used his platform for something other than promoting himself. It is the most consequential. It is also part of a longer pattern that goes back to long before COVID.
He talks about tipping economics on cable. He talks about labor cost on his podcast. He talks about ICE raids on the back of house in interviews where his publicist would prefer he talked about Top Chef. He uses the word "extraction" out loud. Most chefs at his level have never said it once.
He has spoken publicly about credit card processing fees. About delivery platform commissions and the percentage they take from already-thin margins. About the lease structures that have hollowed out independent dining in Manhattan and pushed operators into corners of the boroughs where the rent is still survivable. He has held the position that restaurant workers should be paid a fair wage with no tip credit since before that was a position you could hold without losing fans.
He hosts a podcast called Citizen Chef. The title was not picked by a marketing department.
Twenty-five years on the same block
The reason this matters is that he runs the same gauntlet every operator runs.
Craft opened on East 19th Street between Broadway and Park Avenue South in March 2001. That was twenty-five years ago this spring. The block has changed. The rent has changed. The neighborhood has changed. The restaurant has not closed.
Vallata sits next door at 47 East 19th. Colicchio opened it in 2021, twenty years after Craft, on the same block, in the same lease environment. The lunch menu serves Italian sandwiches Tuesday through Saturday. Pasta and Neapolitan-style pizzas at dinner. Aperitivo specials before 6:30. It is the kind of room a chef builds when he is not trying to perform anything for anyone.
Twenty-five years on a single block in Manhattan is operator work. Anyone can buy a marketing campaign. He knows what his rent does every five years. He knows what his vendors charge. He knows what his line cooks earn after they get home and pay for the train and rent in a borough an hour away from the restaurant. When he goes to Washington and tells a senator how a 4 percent food cost margin actually works, he is not reading from a briefing book.
What cool actually means
Food media's working definition of cool is aesthetic. The sneakers, the menu, the dining room, the wine list, the chef's coat. It is a definition built to sell magazines and Cool Lists and end-of-year roundups. It rewards chefs who perform well in front of a camera and produces a new coolest chef every eighteen months because the magazines need to crown someone different next year.
Colicchio's version is structural. Cool is who you stay loyal to when the cameras stop rolling. Cool is testifying for free for fifteen years on behalf of people whose names will never appear in a New Yorker profile. Cool is keeping a restaurant open on the same block for a quarter century while the neighborhood gets more expensive and the labor pool gets squeezed and the platform fees keep climbing and the city keeps rolling out new fees and new compliance regimes and new licensing windows that take eighteen months to get through.
That is the cool that survives a recession. That is the cool that operators recognize. Most chefs at his level will never earn it because earning it requires giving up things that crowns and Cool Lists and influencer endorsements never ask you to give up.
Eat at his places
Craft. 43 East 19th Street, Flatiron. Open since 2001. Dinner from 5pm.
Vallata. 47 East 19th Street, Flatiron. Italian. Pasta, pizzas, aperitivo. Italian sandwich menu Tuesday through Saturday for lunch. Dinner nightly from 5pm.
Temple Court. 5 Beekman Street, Financial District. Inside The Beekman Hotel. Dinner every evening. Weekend brunch with live jazz Saturday and Sunday.
Three rooms. One chef who never stopped showing up for everyone else's. Spend money in his rooms because the more revenue those three restaurants generate, the more time their owner spends in DC fighting for every other operator in this country.
Reservations at craftedhospitality.com.
Like this? Explore more from:
