For 29 years the Starbucks on Astor Place was where you told people to meet you. It opened on March 30, 1995, at Lafayette Street, facing the Cube, and it closed for good on July 29, 2024. More than two years later the glass is still dark. On Nov. 5 a judge in New York Supreme Court sided with the lender that is trying to take the space from its owners, The Real Deal reported. Everybody involved has a reason the corner is empty. The reasons don't match, and most of the paperwork behind them is public. Here is each side's answer, with who said it.

An empty city street at night lit by streetlights.

Stock photo by Julien on Pexels.

STARBUCKS POURED COFFEE FACING THE CUBE FOR 29 YEARS AND LEFT IN JULY 2024

The store was the 11th Starbucks in New York City, EV Grieve reported, and it took the spot of the Astor Riviera Cafe, which ran around the clock from 1979 until 1994. It had about 4,000 square feet, tall windows and a public restroom, and the restroom mattered. When the store closed, one New Yorker's whole eulogy, as Time Out collected it, was “There goes another public restroom.”

The end was fast. EV Grieve broke the news on Sunday, July 28, 2024, the last day of service. By early the next morning the signs were off and the windows were papered over. Starbucks said the closing was effective July 29 and that it reviews its stores regularly, in a statement EV Grieve and Fox 5 published. It gave no reason. Seventeen people worked there. They had unionized in 2022, and the company said it was working with their union on transfers, Washington Square News reported.

A manager told EV Grieve the landlords had pushed the rent so high that even Starbucks couldn't pay it. The landlord said the opposite. ASG Equities, named in press reports as the owner of 21 Astor, said it had offered Starbucks an extension at “the exact same rent” and was sad to see it go, per Fox 5. Starbucks never confirmed either version. The first disagreement about this corner is two years old and was never settled.

A hand holding a plain paper coffee cup with a lid.

Stock photo by Doğu Tuncer on Pexels.

THE GINDI FAMILY BORROWED $26.65 MILLION IN 2015 AGAINST A CORNER BOUGHT FOR $13 MILLION

The corner is a commercial condo: the ground floor and basement of 21 Astor Place are owned separately from the apartments upstairs. A company now tied to Isaac and Edward Gindi bought that condo in 2004 for $13 million. The city's deed records show the sale, dated June 22, 2004, and The Real Deal reported the same figure. The Gindis are the family behind the Century 21 department stores, and PincusCo, a real estate data firm, describes ASG Equities as the family's investment office.

In July 2015 the owners refinanced. The loan was $26,650,000 at 4.61 percent, due in August 2025, according to an offering document filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. It was interest only, which means the owners paid the interest, about $1.2 million a year, and none of the principal. The document also shows where the money went: about $12.7 million paid off the old mortgage, and about $12.1 million went toward buying out a partner who held the other third of the property. The loan was then bundled with other commercial mortgages and sold to investors. That's why the lender in this story speaks through a servicing company and court papers.

The same document explains how a $13 million purchase could carry a loan twice that size. An appraiser valued the space at $42 million in July 2015. An appraised value is a professional's estimate of what a property would sell for. The space had two tenants and no vacancy: a FedEx store on 6,751 square feet and Starbucks on 4,370. Starbucks was paying about $204 a square foot, roughly $890,000 a year, with raises built in that averaged about $1.03 million a year over the life of the loan. Together the two tenants paid about $2.06 million a year. By those terms the Starbucks lease ran to March 31, 2025, with an option for five more years. It closed eight months before that date.

The rent covered the interest as long as both tenants stayed. They didn't. The other tenant left in 2021, The Real Deal reported, citing Morningstar Credit, a firm that tracks loans like this one. Part of the space was rented again at a lower rent, with free rent up front, and revenue fell about 40 percent. Then Starbucks left too.

A building front of tall dark glass windows.

Stock photo by Egor Komarov on Pexels.

THE LANDLORD BLAMES TAXES, LANDMARK RULES AND SLOW CITY APPROVALS FOR THE EMPTY CORNER

The owners' answer came through their lawyers, Terrance and Darren Oved, in December 2025. The vacancy, they told The Real Deal, “stems from high taxes, complex landmark regulations and lengthy municipal approvals.” They said their client was working on those problems and expected to land a tenant.

There is something behind each item. The loan document describes the space as landmarked, which in New York means a city commission reviews changes to the outside of it. And the taxes are real money: in 2015 the lender had the owners set aside $45,805 a month for property taxes, about $550,000 a year.

What the owners haven't put on the record is a number. They haven't said what rent they've asked for the corner since 2024, how many offers came in, or which approval took how long. Landmark rules and a property tax bill were both in place in 2015, when the space was full.

THE LENDER SAYS THE OWNERS SKIPPED A $1.5 MILLION DEPOSIT WHEN STARBUCKS LEFT

The lender's answer is in the loan itself. The 2015 terms said that if either tenant went dark, gave notice or let its lease run out, “the borrower will be required to deposit the sum of $1,500,000” into a reserve, or post a bank's letter of credit instead. It's a cushion the lender holds while a big tenant's space sits empty.

Starbucks closed in July 2024. The lender says the deposit never came. Its lawsuit, filed in July 2025, also says the owners didn't pay $36,000 in condo charges for 2024, and that the Gindis, who signed a limited guarantee on the loan, didn't turn in the paperwork on their net worth that the loan required, The Real Deal reported. The loan document set that bar at more than $50 million in net worth and $10 million in cash or near-cash. Within months of the closing the loan had been moved to a special servicer, a firm that handles troubled loans for the investors. The Real Deal identified it as Rialto Capital.

The Gindis' lawyers called the allegations wrong on the law and on the facts when the suit was filed, and said they would fight it. The owners also tried to hand over the deed and walk away, according to servicer notes that Morningstar reported. The lender went ahead with foreclosure, the court process in which a lender takes a property, or forces its sale, to recover an unpaid loan. In late November 2025 a court appointed a temporary receiver, a neutral manager who runs a property while a case is open.

The upper floors of an old masonry building seen from the street.

Stock photo by Ebru DOĞAN on Pexels.

A JUDGE RULED FOR THE LENDER ON NOV. 5 WHILE A TENANT NEGOTIATES A LEASE

On Nov. 5 the lender won summary judgment, The Real Deal reported. That means the judge decided the case on the written record, without a trial. The report doesn't name the judge, and lawyers for both sides didn't answer its requests for comment. No auction date is on the record, and neither is an appeal.

By now the numbers have flipped. Morningstar put the space at $11.7 million last December, down from $42 million in 2015, and this year's figure is more than 73 percent below the 2015 one. That works out to less than $11.4 million, against a $26.65 million loan that came due in August 2025. The debt is more than twice what the space is appraised at, and the appraisal is lower than the price The Real Deal says the Gindis' company paid in 2004.

There is one piece of news for people who just want the lights on. The servicer is negotiating a lease with a new tenant for the old Starbucks space, and the receiver began drafting it in September, according to the Morningstar notes The Real Deal cited. The tenant isn't named. Neither is the rent. The lease on the larger part of the condo runs out in January.

So the question has two official answers. The landlord says the city makes the corner hard to rent. The lender says the landlord broke the loan. The loan papers add a third fact: in 2015 this corner was appraised at $42 million because two national tenants paid about $2 million a year for it, and $26.65 million was borrowed against that. Both tenants left. The loan stayed. A corner bought for $13 million was carrying twice that in debt when Starbucks walked out, and it has been empty every day since.

SOURCING

NYC Open Data, ACRIS Real Property Master (deed dated June 22, 2004, recorded July 29, 2004, $13,000,000, Manhattan block 545, lot 1301)

NYC Open Data, ACRIS Real Property Legals (the recorded documents for the commercial condo at 21 Astor Place)

The Real Deal, Lilah Burke, Nov 9, 2026 (summary judgment for the lender on Nov. 5 in New York Supreme Court; the suit filed July 2025; $13 million in 2004 per city records; the $26.7 million refinancing in 2015; the $1.5 million deposit; the offered deed; appraised value down more than 73 percent, per Morningstar Credit; the lease talks and the receiver's draft; the lease expiring in January; no comment from either side's lawyers)

The Real Deal, Lilah Burke, Dec 4, 2025 ($42 million to $11.7 million, per Morningstar Credit; the $26.65 million loan; the second tenant leaving in 2021 and revenue down about 40 percent; the replacement tenant's free rent; the Oved & Oved statement; the temporary receiver)

The Real Deal, Lilah Burke, July 10, 2025 (the foreclosure suit; Rialto Capital as special servicer; the unpaid $36,000 in condo charges; the net-worth paperwork; the Gindis' lawyers' response)

CSAIL 2015-C3 Commercial Mortgage Trust, free writing prospectus filed with the SEC, 2015, Mortgage Loan No. 10, 21 Astor Place ($26,650,000, 4.61 percent, interest only, note dated July 10, 2015, due Aug. 6, 2025; sponsors and guarantors Isaac A. Gindi and Edward Gindi; the $42,000,000 appraisal dated July 1, 2015; 11,121 square feet, landmarked retail condominium; the two tenants, their square footage, rents and lease dates; uses of the loan; the tax reserve; the $1,500,000 major tenant reserve; the net worth and liquidity covenants)

Fox 5 New York, Jennifer Williams, July 29, 2024 (opened 1995; closing effective July 29, 2024; Starbucks's statement; ASG Equities' statement on the lease extension)

EV Grieve, July 28, 2024 (the closing; opened March 30, 1995, the 11th in the city, about 4,000 square feet; the manager's rent claim; unionized in 2022; 17 workers)

EV Grieve, July 29, 2024 (signs removed and windows papered by morning; the landlord's and Starbucks's statements)

EV Grieve, July 30, 2024 (the Astor Riviera Cafe, 1979 to 1994, open around the clock)

EV Grieve, May 4, 2026 (the Starbucks space still vacant)

Time Out New York, Anna Rahmanan, July 30, 2024 (New Yorkers' reactions; the landlord's statement)

Washington Square News, Mariapaula Gonzalez, Sept 10, 2024 (the union, the 17 workers and transfers; Starbucks gave no reason; ASG Equities' denial)

PincusCo, company profile of ASG Equities (the Gindi family's family office; the family owns Century 21)

PincusCo, July 10, 2025, headline only, article behind a paywall (a $26.65 million pre-foreclosure at the Gindis' Greenwich Village retail property)

Reply

Avatar

or to participate