On Oct. 26, Smithfield Foods finished buying Nathan's Famous. Every share turned into $102 in cash, the stock came off the Nasdaq, and by the end of the day all ten Nathan's directors were off the board. One director is left: Shane Smith, Smithfield's chief executive. The two companies valued the deal at about $450 million when they announced it in January. The odd part is that Smithfield didn't need to buy anything to sell the hot dogs. It has made and sold the packs of Nathan's franks in supermarkets since 2014, under a license good through March 2032. It bought the whole company anyway, and the reason is in the paperwork both companies filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, the federal agency public companies report to.

Stock photo by Lisa Fotios on Pexels.
NATHAN HANDWERKER OPENED A NICKEL HOT DOG STAND AT SURF AND STILLWELL WITH $300
Handwerker came from Poland in 1912 and spent weekends slicing rolls at Feltman's German Gardens, the Coney Island restaurant where he met his wife, Ida, the Jewish Telegraphic Agency reported in 2023. In 1916 the two opened their own stand at Surf and Stillwell and charged a nickel, half of what Feltman's got for a hot dog. Ida's spice blend went into the franks, and the company says it still does.
The $300 comes in two versions. Nathan's Famous says the stand opened on a $300 loan, which is how the Associated Press reported it in January. The Philadelphia Daily News, in a 2014 piece that quotes Handwerker's grandson Lloyd, called the $300 the couple's life savings, and the Jewish Telegraphic Agency says they had saved it. The old story that the entertainers Jimmy Durante and Eddie Cantor financed the stand is a myth, Lloyd Handwerker says, the Village Voice reported in 2016. Every account agrees on the number.
The stand is still on that corner, which the city co-named Nathan and Ida Handwerker Way in 2016. It's one of four restaurants the company ran itself as of March, alongside 221 franchised locations. The July 4 hot dog eating contest has aired on ESPN since 2004. All of it, the flagship included, is a small part of what Smithfield bought. The company's own restaurants took in $12.5 million of its $162.1 million in revenue last year.

Stock photo by Caleb Oquendo on Pexels.
SMITHFIELD'S YEARLY CHECKS TO NATHAN'S WERE BIGGER THAN NATHAN'S ENTIRE OPERATING PROFIT LAST YEAR
A license is permission to use a name for a fee. Under this one, signed in 2012 and in force since March 2014, Smithfield got the exclusive right to make and sell Nathan's hot dogs and sausages in packages at Walmart, Kroger, Costco, ShopRite and other chains in all 50 states. The fee, called a royalty, was 10.8 percent of Smithfield's net sales of those packs.
In the year that ended March 29, 2026, the royalties came to $33.6 million: $31.9 million from stores and $1.7 million from a side arrangement covering food-service customers, by Nathan's annual report. By our arithmetic, $31.9 million at 10.8 percent means Smithfield sold roughly $295 million of Nathan's packs in a year.
For Nathan's, that money arrived with almost no cost attached. Its whole licensing business brought in $37.4 million and cost $183,000 to run. Selling hot dogs in bulk to stadiums, movie theaters and gas stations brought in $105.8 million and earned $4.3 million. The restaurants and franchises earned $2.6 million.
Add it up and Nathan's operating profit, what's left after the costs of running the business and before interest and taxes, was $30.1 million. Smithfield's checks alone were bigger than that. The proxy statement, the document a company sends shareholders before they vote on a sale, says the royalties equaled 92 percent of operating income in fiscal 2025 and 103.5 percent in the nine months through December. Nathan's told investors in the annual report that it couldn't promise the license would be renewed.
BUYING THE NAME ENDS THE CHECKS AND THE 2032 DEADLINE THAT CAME WITH THEM
Smithfield's stated reason is in the January announcement. Closing the deal, it said, secures its rights to the brand for good, where the license was set to run out in 2032. Smith said the purchase lets Smithfield "own all of the top brands in our Packaged Meats portfolio." The company also told investors it expects to save about $9 million a year within two years of closing.
The arithmetic is short. From closing day to March 2032 is a little over five years. At last year's rate, Smithfield would have sent Nathan's roughly $180 million in royalties over that stretch, by our count, and then sat down to renegotiate with a company that had told its own shareholders renewal wasn't guaranteed. It was renting a name it had spent twelve years building up in supermarkets. Now it owns it.
Smithfield's own accounting says the same. In the quarterly report it filed the day after closing, it told investors that substantially all of the value of what it acquired sits in the Nathan's Famous trade name. That report puts the cost at $441 million, including $18 million in deal fees, plus $47 million of Nathan's debt, which Smithfield paid off. The shares themselves came to about $418 million, by our arithmetic. The $450 million is the January figure, which counts debt.
Smithfield is majority owned by WH Group, a company based in Hong Kong, according to the same report. That's why the sale needed clearance from the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States, a federal panel that reviews foreign purchases of American companies. Clearance came on Sept. 17.

Stock photo by Jaxon Matthew Willis on Pexels.
SMITHFIELD OPENED AT $100 A SHARE, WALKED AWAY AND CAME BACK AT $102
The proxy lays out the haggling. Smithfield's first written offer, unsolicited, came on May 8, 2025: $100 a share. Within two weeks the stock closed above that, at $103.20. The board said no and in July asked for $120. Smithfield's bankers answered that its view on price was firm, and it stopped talking.
Nathan's bankers at Jefferies told the board more than once what the license meant for a sale. So much of the company's earnings came from Smithfield, and the license had so long to run, that other food companies were unlikely bidders. Buyout firms were unlikely to pay even the market price. And after months of press reports that Nathan's was for sale, nobody else had called.
In November the board declared a special dividend of $2.50 a share. Two weeks later Smithfield came back at $102. The board asked for $105, and Smithfield went to $103.50 and called it final. Then in January its bankers said a review of the books had turned up about $20 million in possible costs, and the offer dropped to $101. Jefferies disagreed strongly, the proxy says, and the two sides settled back at $102 and signed on Jan. 20. The proxy doesn't say what those costs were.
The board's stated reasons for accepting were cash, certainty and its belief that $102 was "the highest price reasonably available." It also listed the license's remaining term among the things weighing on any other deal. Shareholders approved on Oct. 23, with 3,229,773 shares in favor and 28,025 against. Two shareholders sued in New York state court, saying the proxy was misleading. Nathan's said the claims had no merit and added disclosures before the vote.
One more term shows what Smithfield was after. If Washington had blocked the sale, Nathan's could have taken a $7.4 million fee, and in exchange Smithfield would have gotten four more years on the license, to March 2036. Smithfield first asked for ten.

Stock photo by Efe Ersoy on Pexels.
THE CHAIRMAN'S SHARES PAID $101 MILLION AND THE STAND'S LEASES RUN OUT IN 2027
Howard Lorber, the executive chairman, held 989,841 shares, 24.2 percent of the company. At $102, the proxy values them at $100,963,782. Directors and officers together held 31 percent. Funds run by Mario Gabelli's firms held 440,561 shares, about $44.9 million by our arithmetic. Eric Gatoff, the chief executive, had shares worth about $8 million and a $3.25 million bonus for staying through the closing. The whole board left when the sale took effect, which is standard when a company is bought outright, and Gatoff signed the closing-day filing as chief executive.
As for Coney Island, Smithfield said in January that the July 4 contest will continue, the AP reported. The merger agreement requires Smithfield to keep pay and benefits for Nathan's employees who stay at least as good, overall, for nine months after closing. Nathan's had 129 year-round employees in March and hires about 240 to 250 more each summer. The leases on the Surf Avenue flagship and the Boardwalk stand expire in December 2027 and November 2027. We found no statement from either company about the leases, about prices at the counter, or about what happens after the nine months.
Nathan's has sold hot dogs at Surf and Stillwell for 110 years, and by the end the stand was a small piece of a company living on one customer's checks. That customer was paying $33.6 million a year to borrow a name, on a license with an end date. It bought the name, the recipe and the corner. The decisions about all three are made in Smithfield, Virginia, now.
SOURCING
Nathan's Famous, annual report on Form 10-K for the year ended March 29, 2026, filed June 9, 2026 (the license terms, expiry in March 2032, the 10.8 percent royalty, $31,893,000 and $1,696,000 in Smithfield royalties, 21 percent of revenue, total revenue $162,063,000, income from operations $30,102,000, the segment table, company-owned restaurant sales $12,508,000, four company-owned restaurants and 221 franchised locations, 129 employees and 240 to 250 seasonal, the Coney Island leases, ESPN since 2004, Ida Handwerker's spice blend, the renewal warning): sec.gov
Nathan's Famous, definitive merger proxy statement, filed Sept. 24, 2026 (royalties as 92.5, 92.0 and 103.5 percent of operating income; the May 8, 2025 offer at $100; the $120 counter; the July 30 walk-away; Jefferies' advice on other buyers; the $2.50 special dividend; $102, $105, $103.50, $101 and $102; the roughly $20 million of possible costs; the board's reasons; the $7,407,270 fee and the four-year license extension, first proposed at ten; clearance on Sept. 17, 2026; Howard Lorber's 989,841 shares valued at $100,963,782; directors and officers at 31.0 percent; GAMCO at 440,561 shares; Eric Gatoff's shares and $3,250,000 retention bonus; 4,097,661 shares outstanding; nine months of pay and benefits for continuing employees): sec.gov
Nathan's Famous, current report on Form 8-K, Oct. 26, 2026 (the closing, $102.00 a share, the ten directors named, C. Shane Smith as sole director, the Nasdaq delisting request, signed by Eric Gatoff as chief executive): sec.gov
Nathan's Famous, current report on Form 8-K, Oct. 23, 2026 (the shareholder vote: 3,229,773 for, 28,025 against, 18,213 abstaining): sec.gov
Nathan's Famous, current report on Form 8-K, Oct. 14, 2026 (the two shareholder suits in New York state court, the company's position that the claims are without merit, the added disclosures): sec.gov
Smithfield Foods and Nathan's Famous, joint press release, Jan. 21, 2026, filed as an exhibit to Nathan's Form 8-K (enterprise value of approximately $450 million, the license since March 2014 and its March 2032 expiry, rights "into perpetuity", Shane Smith's statement, about $9 million a year in savings, Smithfield, Virginia): sec.gov
Smithfield Foods, quarterly report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended Sept. 27, 2026, filed Oct. 27, 2026 ($441 million including $18 million in transaction costs, $47 million of assumed debt, value concentrated in the trade name, majority owned by Hong Kong-based WH Group): sec.gov
Smithfield Foods, third-quarter results release, Oct. 27, 2026 (the acquisition completed Oct. 26): sec.gov
Associated Press, Matt Ott, via ABC7 New York, Jan. 21, 2026 ($450 million, $102 a share, "a $300 loan, according to the company", Smithfield's 2024 sales of $14.1 billion, the July 4 contest to continue): abc7ny.com
Brooklyn Paper, January 2026 ($450 million, the license from 2014 to 2032, the $300 loan, both companies on keeping the contest): brooklynpaper.com
Investing.com, Oct. 26, 2026 (the completed merger, the directors, the delisting): investing.com
Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Julia Gergely, Sept. 26, 2023 (arrival in 1912, Feltman's, the saved $300, the nickel at half Feltman's price, Ida's recipe, Nathan and Ida Handwerker Way in 2016): jta.org
Philadelphia Daily News via Inquirer.com, Beth D'Addono, Oct. 30, 2014 (the $300 as the couple's life savings, the nickel): inquirer.com
The Village Voice, Matt Gross, June 1, 2016 (Lloyd Handwerker on the Durante and Cantor story as a myth): villagevoice.com
The Standard (Hong Kong), Jan. 22, 2026 (Smithfield as a majority-owned subsidiary of WH Group): thestandard.com.hk







