Greenwich Village, Manhattan. Babbo is still on Waverly Place. It still fills. His name has not been on it since March 2019 and almost nobody who books a table brings it up.
THE SETUP
If you ate Italian food in this city between 2000 and 2017, you ate inside his influence whether or not you ever walked into one of his dining rooms. Then it ended in fifteen months, and the ending got less attention than any single opening ever did.
THE EMPIRE
Babbo opened in 1998 and made booking a month out feel normal for a restaurant that was not French. Del Posto held four stars from the Times, the only Italian restaurant in the city ever to get there. Lupa, Esca, Casa Mono, Otto. Then Eataly landed in the Flatiron in 2010 and turned a block of Fifth Avenue into a destination people flew in for.
Sixteen restaurants carried his stake. The orange clogs were a personality half the industry borrowed. He was on daytime television five days a week.
FIFTEEN MONTHS
In December 2017, Eater published the accounts of four women describing unwanted touching over a period of years. More accounts followed. He stepped away from daily operations within days.
By March 2019 the Bastianich family had bought out every share he held across the restaurant group. Eataly took back his stake separately. ABC canceled The Chew. The name came off the paperwork, the menus and the doors inside fifteen months of the first story running.
THE RECEIPTS
In 2021 he and his business partners paid 600,000 dollars to settle a New York Attorney General investigation into harassment of employees at the restaurants. The money went to former workers.
In May 2022 a Boston judge acquitted him of indecent assault and battery in a separate criminal case, finding credibility problems with the complaining witness. The same judge said from the bench that his conduct that night was not behavior befitting someone of his public standing.
Both of those are true at once. That is the part that makes this hard to file away.
WHERE HE IS NOW
Northern Michigan. Occasional recipe posts. No restaurants under his name, in this city or any other.
There was no comeback tour, no rehabilitation interview cycle, no quiet return to a kitchen in another market. For a man who spent twenty years making sure everybody knew where he was, the silence is the loudest fact in the file.
THE ROOMS ARE STILL OPEN
Here is what New York actually did with all of it. Nothing visible. Babbo is open. Lupa is open. Eataly is packed on a Tuesday. The cooks who were on those lines are still cooking, most of them somewhere else now, and the servers who worked those floors built careers on rooms that are still running under different ownership.
A city that argues about a pastrami sandwich for ten years processed the fastest collapse in its restaurant history by simply not mentioning it again. The buildings absorbed it. The staff absorbed it. The reservations never dipped for long.
That is not forgiveness and it is not amnesia. It is something New York does that nowhere else does, which is to keep the room and discard the man, and then serve dinner at six.
SO WE ARE ASKING
What do you actually remember about this guy. Not what you are supposed to say about him. What you remember, and where you land on him now.
The rooms are still open. Still staffed. Still feeding people who never knew whose name used to be on the lease.








