Logo
magnifying-glass
Search
sign-in
Sign In
pencil-simple-line
Subscribe
Oliver Buchannon
Reagan Payne

For The Culture

WHY EDDIE’S SWEET SHOP STILL WINS WITH HAND MIXED COKES AND REAL HOT FUDGE

Mar 18, 2026

•

3 min read

WHY EDDIE’S SWEET SHOP STILL WINS WITH HAND MIXED COKES AND REAL HOT FUDGE

There’s a Forest Hills soda fountain that’s somehow always tucked under some scaffolding has survived every dessert trend by sticking to house made ice cream, hand stirred sodas, and zero frills.

Reagan Payne
Reagan Payne

Off The Menu

I HATE BIG BITES AND I CANNOT LIE: THE CASE AGAINST OVERSTUFFED SANDWICHES

Mar 12, 2026

•

2 min read

I HATE BIG BITES AND I CANNOT LIE: THE CASE AGAINST OVERSTUFFED SANDWICHES

This is my anti-overstuffed sandwich manifesto calling out NYC delis that prioritize towering meat mountains over bite balance, diner dignity, and the simple pleasure of a sandwich.

Reagan Payne
Reagan Payne

Off The Menu

TO SPOT VENTURE CAPITAL VS. THE CULTURE THEY COPY

Mar 11, 2026

•

3 min read

TO SPOT VENTURE CAPITAL VS. THE CULTURE THEY COPY

Venture-backed spots are a brand first and foremost. OG spots are real restaurants. Here’s how to spot the difference in NYC before you even read the menu.

Reagan Payne
Reagan Payne

Off The Menu

IF HERSHEY’S HAS NO HATERS, I’M DEAD

Mar 6, 2026

•

4 min read

IF HERSHEY’S HAS NO HATERS, I’M DEAD

Let’s be honest: I don’t hate Hershey’s because of the heavy metals in their chocolate.I hate Hershey’s because it’s everywhere and tastes like nothing... or maybe too much of the wrong thing.

Reagan Payne
Reagan Payne

Off The Menu

FINE... FINE DINING

Mar 4, 2026

•

4 min read

FINE... FINE DINING

Fine dining isn’t dead... but I think it’s unnecessary.

Reagan Payne
Reagan Payne

For The Culture

AFRAID OF THE ICK? HERE ARE THE SPOTS YOUR FIRST DATE SHOULD NEVER BE

Mar 3, 2026

•

4 min read

AFRAID OF THE ICK? HERE ARE THE SPOTS YOUR FIRST DATE SHOULD NEVER BE

NYC turned non-alcoholic cocktails into overpriced fruit sugar with branding. Some spots still care, but most are serving melted gummies at full Manhattan prices.

Reagan Payne
Reagan Payne

Off The Menu

BUYING LUNCH IN BROOKLYN? CONSIDER THIS GROCERY STORE COMMISSARY

Feb 27, 2026

•

3 min read

BUYING LUNCH IN BROOKLYN? CONSIDER THIS GROCERY STORE COMMISSARY

In a world where every day brings less bang for your buck, Jubilee Marketplace prioritizes people over prices. Brooklyn is expensive.

Reagan Payne
Reagan Payne

Off The Menu

PURE CONFIDENCE KEEPS KATIE O’S OPEN ONLY 3 DAYS A WEEK

Feb 25, 2026

•

4 min read

PURE CONFIDENCE KEEPS KATIE O’S OPEN ONLY 3 DAYS A WEEK

Most places that are only open a few days a week are 100% pulling some fake scarcity bullshit. Restaurants want you to work so hard to schedule your meals around them. Katie O’s is the exception.

Reagan Payne
Reagan Payne

Off The Menu

SUBWAY SUPPERS

Feb 21, 2026

•

4 min read

SUBWAY SUPPERS

This city could quietly run solely on food eaten between stops. I present you: something to finish between boroughs. I bring you: snacks that defy gravity, are safeguarded from elbows, and are stable throughout sudden braking.

Reagan Payne
Reagan Payne

Off The Menu

FOOD, WATER, ATMOSPHERE? YOU'RE TOO HUNG UP ON HOW A PLACE PHOTOGRAPHS

Feb 17, 2026

•

3 min read

FOOD, WATER, ATMOSPHERE? YOU'RE TOO HUNG UP ON HOW A PLACE PHOTOGRAPHS

A SpongeBob scene (no surprise) nailed a modern dining delusion. Stop wondering why your stomach feels empty after a reservation.

Reagan Payne
Reagan Payne

Off The Menu

“JUST FINE” DINING

Feb 14, 2026

•

2 min read

“JUST FINE” DINING

NYC’s hardest reservations sell you status, not dinner: Carbone, Via Carota, Don Angie, and Eleven Madison Park. Relax. The word on the street is: you need to relax. The struggle is not real, it’s entirely optional.

Reagan Payne
Reagan Payne

Off The Menu

WORLD’S BEST CUP OF COFFEE (ACTUALLY) (NYC EDITION)

Jan 28, 2026

•

3 min read

WORLD’S BEST CUP OF COFFEE (ACTUALLY) (NYC EDITION)

We laughed... but Buddy the Elf raises a real question. In one of the world’s most caffeinated cities, where can we find a consistently excellent espresso or drip cup you can trust? Where is the World’s NYC’s Best Cup of Coffee?

Reagan Payne
Reagan Payne

Born Hungry™

Protecting NYC's Real Food Culture

New York Eats Here is a We Eat Here Production